Brilliant Earth Review

This article has mentions of products from one or more companies, and I may receive compensation if you purchase those products following reading my recommendations.

In this Brilliant Earth Lab Diamonds Review, we delve into the offerings of a brand that has positioned itself as a leader in ethically sourced and environmentally responsible jewelry. While their mission and commitment to sustainability are commendable, it’s essential to scrutinize the quality of their diamonds and the veracity of their marketing claims.

History of Brilliant Earth

Founded with a vision to transform the jewelry industry, Brilliant Earth has been at the forefront of promoting transparency, sustainability, and ethical sourcing. Their journey began with the introduction of the “Beyond Conflict FreeTM Diamonds” standard, aiming to provide diamonds that not only avoid funding conflict but are also sourced responsibly. This rigorous protocol for diamond sourcing was a step beyond the industry’s existing practices.

Brilliant Earth’s commitment to ethical sourcing is further highlighted by their blockchain-enabled diamonds, providing unparalleled transparency regarding a diamond’s origin and ownership. They have also made strides in using 100% recycled precious metals, reducing the environmental impact associated with metal mining.

Moreover, their social initiatives, such as the Brilliant Earth Foundation, reflect their dedication to giving back. They support various programs aimed at improving social and environmental practices, including education & vocational training, fair mining practices, and land restoration efforts.

Brilliant Earth Lab Diamonds Review

Brilliant Earth has made commendable strides in the realm of lab-grown diamonds. Their offerings span across various categories, each with its unique appeal:

Carbon Capture Diamonds: These diamonds are a testament to Brilliant Earth’s commitment to sustainability. By capturing carbon from the atmosphere during the diamond creation process, they’re not only producing beautiful gems but also contributing positively to the environment.

Renewable Energy Diamonds: Another step towards eco-friendliness, these diamonds are crafted using renewable energy sources, ensuring a reduced carbon footprint.

Colored Lab Diamonds: For those looking for something unique, Brilliant Earth’s lab-created colored diamonds are a treat. They offer a range of hues from intense pinks to vivid blues. If colored diamonds are what you’re after, this collection is certainly worth exploring.

Sustainably Rated Lab Diamonds: This collection stands out for its independent sustainability rating. Each diamond is evaluated based on climate neutrality and investments in clean technology, setting new standards in sustainable lab diamond production.

1.23 Carat Emerald Lab Created Diamond from Brilliant Earth

While Brilliant Earth’s efforts in promoting sustainable and ethically produced diamonds are praiseworthy, when it comes to sheer quality, other brands might have an edge. Whiteflash’s Precision Lab Diamonds are known for its precision-cut diamonds that exude brilliance. Similarly, James Allen occasionally offers diamonds that might surpass in quality.

Brilliant Earth’s lab diamonds, especially their colored variants, are a fantastic choice for the environmentally conscious buyer. However, for those prioritizing diamond quality above all else, exploring other brands might be beneficial.

Website Review

Brilliant Earth’s website is a testament to user-friendliness and seamless navigation. The layout is intuitive, making it easy for visitors to find what they’re looking for. The site is rich in information, from detailed product listings to educational resources about diamonds and gemstones. The inclusion of virtual appointments and live chat features further enhances the user experience, allowing customers to get personalized assistance in real-time. Overall, Brilliant Earth has done an exceptional job in creating a platform that is both informative and easy to navigate, making the jewelry shopping experience a pleasure.

Packaging Review

Brilliant Earth’s commitment to sustainability is evident not just in their jewelry but also in their packaging. Their responsibly sourced wood ring boxes are as iconic as the jewelry they hold. Crafted with wood from Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certified forests, these boxes ensure that the forests are responsibly managed for future generations. Additionally, their shipping packaging is sourced responsibly, and they continuously aim to reduce packaging waste. For ring orders over $1,000 that include diamonds or gemstones, they also provide a complimentary non-toxic biodegradable jewelry cleaner. This attention to detail and commitment to the environment sets Brilliant Earth apart in the jewelry industry.

Returns Policy Review

Brilliant Earth’s returns policy for UK customers is fairly standard. Customers who are not satisfied with their order can return their jewelry item within 30 days of shipment. The company offers free return shipping on all orders and provides a free FedEx return shipping label to ensure the return process is seamless and easy. Additionally, if the ring size isn’t a perfect fit, Brilliant Earth offers a free resize within 60 days of shipment, within the jeweler’s recommended sizing tolerance.

For customers in the US and Canada, the returns policy is quite accommodating. They offer complimentary 30-day returns and 60-day resizes. This means that if for any reason a customer is not satisfied with their purchase, they can return it within 30 days for an exchange or full refund. Brilliant Earth also provides free FedEx return shipping labels for all ring, loose diamond, loose gemstone, and finished jewelry orders, making the return process hassle-free. Within 60 days of when the purchase is available for shipment or pickup, they offer one complimentary resizing for standard ring styles. However, it’s worth noting that eternity rings cannot be resized due to their design, and custom, modified, and engraved rings are subject to resize fees.

While the policy is straightforward and customer-friendly, it doesn’t particularly stand out from what many other jewelers offer, making it relatively ordinary in the industry.


Brilliant Earth has carved a niche for itself in the jewelry industry with its unwavering commitment to sustainability, ethical sourcing, and user-friendly online experience. They excel in many areas, from their eco-friendly packaging to their transparent and accommodating return policies. Their dedication to providing consumers with ethically sourced and environmentally friendly jewelry options is commendable.

However, when it comes to the pinnacle of diamond quality, there are other contenders. Whiteflash’s Precision Lab Diamonds are renowned for their precision-cut diamonds that exude unmatched brilliance. For those exploring other options, James Allen and Blue Nile are also worth considering, as they offer a wide range of high-quality diamonds and jewelry.

In conclusion, Brilliant Earth does many things exceptionally well, and they’ve set a high bar in the industry, especially in terms of sustainability and ethical practices. They earn a solid 4/5 for their overall offerings.

Brilliant Earth Lab Diamonds Review

Name: Brilliant Earth

Description: Brilliant Earth is a San Francisco-based jewelry company founded in 2005 by Beth Gerstein and Eric Grossberg. Renowned for ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones, they offer both natural and lab-created diamonds. The company emphasizes sustainability, using recycled materials, and supports African communities impacted by conflict diamonds.

  • Diamond Quality
  • Selection
  • Price
  • Website Usability

Welcome to Lab Diamonds Reviews

My primary goal is to offer a free diamond buying help service. With the myriad of choices available in the market, I understand the challenges buyers face.

Latest Blog Posts